Bad Parents of the World, Unite!

I want to dissolve the taboo we all have about interrupting each other’s toxic parenting in public or when we’re with our friends and family. It’s a taboo only because it is so shameful how we treat our kids sometimes that being pulled out of it in the moment, the sudden raw exposure feels violating. But we NEED now at this point in our evolution as a species to empathically and constructively flag each other’s irresponsible, dumpy, coercive, domineering treatment of our children. This silent contract must end now.

I was in a queue recently at a festival and a woman behind me was holding her 4 year old boy. The kid saw a lolly on the counter and instinctively said “I want that!” He didn’t even have a whiny tinge in his tone like my kids sometimes open with. Unbelievably, the woman, like a hypnotic snaky shadow replied, “…don’t say that, that’s greedy, you don’t want to be a greedy boy…” really getting into his head – or like Jimmi Hendrix said “too many fingerprints on his brain” – and she didn’t stop there – “‘What a greedy boy’ they’ll say, and no one will want to play with you, we don’t want to play with him they’ll say'” – really hypnotic and suppressing – I felt claustrophobia course through my veins and wanted to stop her. I thought, ‘my God, imagine being that kid day after day in their home. You’d end up a murderer.’

I also get stirred up when I see parents not stepping up to give their kids boundaries because they appear to be so in need of their kids approval that they’d rather be liked than be a parent. In some realms of psychology they say that the baby learns that it is loveable because it sees itself mirrored in its mother’s loving eyes. The infant draws it’s identity as a loveable being from the mirror of the Mother’s adoring gaze, but now so many Mothers and Fathers have switched the contract on their kids and are looking into their kids’ eyes to be reassured that they themselves are loved! Avoiding giving kids boundaries and letting them rule the roost as ‘pack leaders’ breeds domineering bullies. We need to step up and up our game.

It’s time to drop the taboo on discussing irresponsible parenting and get it together. TOGETHER.

My partner Raisa busted me brilliantly recently with my girls. They were playing up in the car and after repeated semi-empty threats I finally came down with a consequence boundary and cancelled the movie that we’d all planned to watch later. It temporarily had the desired effect of shutting them up in sulky shock that a real line had been drawn. But of course, a few hours later, when we had got home, eaten, cuddled, and it was 7.30pm, there wasn’t even a wisp of the earlier drama present so I dissolved the earlier punishment and got up to put on the film. This is where having a partner as ON IT and articulate as Raisa is such a gift. She takes me aside and says “If you keep drawing boundaries like earlier and then changing your mind later, these girls won’t trust you, and they won’t trust men.” And I knew every syllable was true. I felt something shift in me and a deeper resolve to get us all as parents upping our game and making the collective decision to lift this regressive taboo on feeding back what we’re witnessing in each other’s parenting.

We’re going to have to cultivate a new relationship with our SHAME – the shame of being seen in reactive bad-parenting mode and the shame we are instilling in our kids in all the moments we can’t hold onto our own emotionally reactive beans and we leak out our dumpy, irresponsible, shaming manipulations on our kids. When we shout at our kids with a closed heart, it is toxic for them. When we rebuke in a sing-song voice through gritted teeth, it is toxic for the kids. When we vent our frustration at them for their non-compliance with our rules and instructions, or when we try and coerce them either with rewards or punishments we are confusing their minds and hearts.

This is going to require some radical rethinking of the habitual ways we control the children. Even the phrase ‘good boy’ or ‘good girl’ is an approval manipulation, meant in the best possible way, but instills a need in the kid to be good not bad, for Your love. Not because their values are in harmony but because they fear your ‘love-withhold’. As kids, when we are trained by our carers to eat and poo and walk and speak, we are rewarded with kisses and prizes when we ‘get it right’ and we don’t get the same warm gusts of approval when we ‘don’t get it right’ – so we become Approval Addicts and the moment this happens, as Anthony de Mello says ‘society can control you’. We are slaves to approval, we are all conforming to some sector of approval, to be good earners, good workers, good home-makers, good looking – the core of Facebook is LIKING things, how many approval points did you get on that post, that picture, that insight? So just as a start, if we want to cultivate Freedom, it’s more useful to call the kids’ behaviour Good and Naughty but not the kid themself good or naughty. There’s a big mental and emotional difference between “Jamie, you’re a naughty boy!” and “Jamie, that is a very naughty thing to do!” Yes, obvious to some.

There are grey areas in all this but let’s dissolve the taboo.

We parents are also the most doting, careful, clued-up generation of parents this planet has EVER seen. These are the luckiest kids that have ever been born. That’s why, this is the time, we’ve reached a point where we care enough to get Active with this stuff. We agonise over our anger, our over-indulgence, our feelings of being sometimes overwhelmed. We care about the GMO foods that we want to protect our kids from, we care about the refined sugar that has been toxifying so much of the kids digestive and immune systems to make profits for rich crooks. We care about the country’s resources and hard earned taxes not being spent on wonderful palatial schools for our kids where their Creativity is devotionally cherished and all kinds of education, NOT just Academic, but visual, sonic, movement, imagination, even spiritual – All sides of kids are valued.

If we want to build this reality for our kids we need to raise our presence with how we as parents are treating our kids. When we dissolve this taboo together within our families and within our hearts, just watch the external factors in than list above transform all by themselves. Those toxic worldly issues are perfect mirrors of our own issues with our treatment of our kids.

They had to make a law to say we can’t beat them to teach with pain?

Parents of 2014 – Stand up for your kids. Let’s gift the future generations with massively more conscious and present mental and emotional wellbeing.

please join this group here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/badparentsoftheworldunite/

31 comments

  1. We know the difference between right and wrong. We know what freedom feels like. When we supress freedom and imagination to explore in our children I think that is just about the biggest possible crime on humanity. Children are naturally altruistic that is what we should encourage, taking risks not telling them to “be careful” – fab article. I’d book the course if I could get the childcare cover.

  2. You said it all in the first paragraph!!!
    Yes, “the silent contract must end now”.. I am sure many of us agree with you, but it needs to be said. Publicly and loud. Good thing you are doing it.
    As a single full time mother and a rebel who resents authority, I am very flexible with most rules and the boundaries are basic. We respect each other as equals. There are no punishments, and my son is rewarded just for being. However, he understand that I am a better person when I am happy, and if I am having a bad day, I let him know I am more likely to shout or snap quicker if he does not listen to me and does what I KINDLY (: asks him to do, Heknows that if he behaves nastily or disrespectfully he will probably be ignored. So far, I believe love has done its job. He is a very kind soul with most of the world and most of the time, even when he behaves like a 9 year old monster with me.
    I admit I have my trauma with approval and I want to be loved and liked, but I live with him and I cannot be other than me at home. Just like him.

  3. x Thank you Jamie for this. I’m not a parent (yet) but my sister-in-law is about to be for the first time and I will definitely pass this on to her. I have often wanted to gently suggest a different, more helpful tact to parents in public but have felt unqualified and know that that type of intrusion is not appreciated (for the reasons you highlight) so I will now endeavour to do it anyway with love in my heart, all the way, even during what might be an unpleasant reaction. More often I have internally rebuked the mother/father in question without wondering very deeply about how the situation could have been handled differently so I’ll try more of this.

    Thanks again, a future mother/trainee-mum

    Blessed love x

  4. I think it’s interesting couples have to take classes before getting married in most churches but parenting classes are not required.
    I really don’t think many parents have a clue as to how to raise their children. They go by what their parents did, if the outcome felt good…or they learned what not to do. It would be nice to introduce imprints of more value based options.

  5. Brilliant….how about working for the govn on the ‘troubled families’ agenda. I say that a bit tongue in cheek but OMG that would be such a gift ❤

  6. I’m not a parent so you might say I have no right to comment but I teach children and am recently having to parent my inner child who didn’t get any, having been away at boarding school from the age of eight. I have come to know (but find it hard to do) that listening, attention, hearing, noticing, presence, and discussing and negotiating is the way to go. Children are people and deserve no different respect or attention than adults. There are ways to lay down boundaries and have the final say that doesnt negate their feelings or needs. The important thing is to hear what their (real) need is. It’s not necessarily the ice cream. That’s where we as adults can use our wisdom and perception.

  7. Great post.

    I think good parenting is instinctively in all us, what we call a ‘gut feeling’, from the very start of pregnancy but it is often negatively influenced by external pressures such as religion, society and economics. Each child is different and so there are no strict rules, so follow these instincts. I learned this when my first baby was young; no books can tell you the answer, they all send mixed messages. We all make mistakes, we are human and that is where the ‘guilt’ comes from and indeed what the ‘guilt’ is there for, so we do not repeat the mistakes. To explain to a child that you made a mistake can only be good experience for a child. You can still stay consistent and strong in the eyes of the child. Children learn from this and if they feel loved, stable and cared for by both male and female (in their own unique and instinctive ways), these experiences (good and bad) will pave the way to a stable foundation for life. They have the tools to become strong and independent individuals with the vast knowledge under their belt of how to handle situations.
    I think sometimes you have to say ‘no’ to a child, or shout, when they are about to endanger themselves or someone else. The reactions in us are strong and harsh when we see our child about to run into the road, it’s for a reason and we should go with this. Do we care if we embarrass ourselves socially at these times? But after, it’s essential to spend time explaining these actions, why you did this, so the child can understand and learn. Your children are going to say those terrible words “i hate you” at some point and that’s fine because again they will experience guilt and as long as you talk about it later, it’s another experience for them.
    I would say try to go with your own instincts with children and put aside the social pressures which as Jamie says, are nonsense.

  8. I think too many people spend far too much time trying to be their children’s ‘mate’ than a parent………..worried about saying no and not being liked (as said earlier)…..plenty of time to be a ‘mate’ when they are older and hopefully more reasonable !!! hahahaha
    Also many people have generations of ‘bad parenting’ (whatever that may be) and don’t have these instincts or knowledge….how do you seek help if you have no awareness that what you are doing might not be the best ?

  9. Do you suggest we interrupt strangers’ bad parenting? What do we say to the shaming mother in the festival line, without shaming her & making life even more miserable for both mother & child?

  10. The problem is that if you don’t shame and psychologically suppress children you’ll end up with bright, challenging, lively little monkeys who will run you ragged, exhaust you and have you wishing you’d chosen to be a dolphin instead 😉

  11. Just a thought but have you ever read Knots by R D Laing? I just read it again (it’s been getting dusty on the bookshelf) but thanks to this article I have shaken it off and drank it in with a new head on my shoulders. I think you would like it a lot, and your lovely lady also 🙂

  12. I think we as parents/people have good days and bad days, good hours/weeks/months etc. and bad hours/weeks/months etc., when things are good it is easy, and yes, you could say we “instinctively” know how to deal with things. But when we are having a bad patch it is so SO much harder, we may do and say things we regret, and then feel sh*t about it and beat ourselves up with guilt etc…. So, be careful not to judge too harshly. This is when talking, discussing and apologizing is extra important.
    Also, my mum was rubbish with boundaries and I’ve got to say it didn’t help me and I would have respected her more had she occasionally been firmer and stuck to it. Some boundaries teach respect and also show love and care.
    I think Alexandra said it very well when she said “that listening, attention, hearing, noticing, presence, and discussing and negotiating is the way to go.”
    great thought provoking article ~ thanks x

  13. I’ve been impressed by the ideas promoted by the “Taking Children Seriously” website. Their idea is that it is possible and preferable to raise children without coercion using the tools of “finding common preferences”. I’ve used the ideas and tools provided by TCS and found they work brilliantly but are much more demanding of parents patience and thoughtfulness than the usual emotioni reactions which are produced automatically.
    I wondered from your article if you think it’s a good idea to tell children “That behaviour is naughty. That behaviour is good.” I don’t find this way of talking to children helpful at all. Explanations work, but require more effort, “naughty” doesn’t mean anything, except that it’s a behavour you don’t like for some unknown reason. Even saying this or that is “good” or not good it not helpful. It’s not very informative for the child. What makes something good?
    The main thing, I’ve found, is to keep the relationship in tact with respect, non-coercion, offering your “best theory” (pace TCS) to the child and letting them choose as much as you can. In TCS they say when you talk to yourr child, imagine your saying this to another adult. If you wouldn’t speak to an adult that way, it probably isn’t appropriate for a child either. The idea is to give the child the respect you would give an adult. Strangely enough this is a really radical idea in English / British culture and a lot of people do find treating children as equally worthy of respect pretty objectionable. But those of us who get it, really get it. I’m so glad I found TCS (with whom I have no link apart from reading their stuff).
    I’m glad you’re promoting thoughtful parenting. Perhaps you have some good suggestions on what words to use when intervening when parents / carers are shouting at or hitting a child?
    Thanks for your blog. It’s valuable..

    • Agree with every word you’ve said, Isabelle. Children are treated as pre-people that must be civilised with rules and boundaries rather than fellow human beings on a different part of their journey than, perhaps, we as parents are. I’m going straight to ”Taking Children Seriously”.

  14. I heard a woman say to her lovely quiet little boy- “Don’t do that, you’ll be the freak nobody will want to play with. They’ll look at you and move away. Do you want that?” I think he picked up his food with his fingers or something. I glared at her and couldn’t help but say audibly to my husband- “Did she really say THAT!?” I’ve heard Mum’s yell at their kids to SIT DOWN (etc) after being nice about it all day, we all have those moments, but this was insidious. I shuddered, perhaps because I may have heard my Mother doing it to me way back when.

  15. Fact is, if you are a parent who is still traumatised by your own upbringing, the mental ideas of progressive parenting are useful. But, in the moment, your trauma may be triggered and you revert to your family culture (of violence – at least emotional violence). Then you say – YOU are lazy, don’t be greedy – or much worse. What do you do in that moment?
    I know I was treated WAY worse, everyday, than my child gets on our worst days and yet, it’s important to own up to your own bad behaviour as parents. The best I can do in these is be kind to myself and show (proportional) remorse for my words. I drop to my knees and look him in the eye and say, ‘Scrap that. That’s not true. You are wonderful the way you are.’ I can try to explain simply what I mean, but be careful not to analyse the psychology to a little child.
    This shows him I am not perfect, life is somewhat messy, and there are ways of showing respect for the self and others.
    xx

  16. Yes…agree , have been all of the above and am conscious of it …did start out reading Alfie Kohn parenting guide which supported new ways of being with children and adults too actually, awesome take ..you may enjoy taking a look if you haven’t already Jamie 🙂 x

  17. Today at the Coop a man was asking his child in a buggy ‘Do you want some cheese ? what kind shall we get?’ … later in another aisle he was still asking.. ‘Do you want some pasta’? and the child was shouting ‘I want pasta. I WANT pasta !!!’ (I’m Wishing now I’d read this piece as was sorely tempted to speak with him and pass on my mother’s advice of avoiding the ‘ Do you want’ question that seems to pervade modern parenting with every action addressed to the child as if it were their choice….’Do you want to go home now? Do you want some dinner ?.. How confusing and pressuring for the child to be responsible for decisions that rightly belong to a parent, and, like the woman in the festival queue, hearing the phase ‘I want!!’ come back to haunt you.) This is where I’d take issue with our generation being the most ‘clued up’. In so many ways our confusion around authority and freedom has made us quite ridiculous! We are still very much feeling our way.

Leave a reply to Carrie Cancel reply